We’ve enjoyed this BBQ Pulled Pork Stuffed Jalapenos Recipe for appetizers, lunches, and even put an egg on top for breakfast. Oh yes, I said breakfast! With any luck, you’ve already got leftover pulled pork just waiting to create some magic beyond the bun. If not, here’s a Grilled BBQ Pulled Pork Recipe well worth diving into.

First, you’ll want to select fresh jalapenos with some heat so there is a nice contrast in flavor with the pulled pork and cheese.

Did you know not all jalapenos are hot? It’s true.

I’ve been disappointed more than once expecting a nice zing from my jalapeno popper and then … no tingling on my tongue, no highlight of heat, nadda. (This is where I sadly push the sour cream aside.) And then there’s the pepper that is so hot it burns all the way through.

That’s when you start thinking mild has its advantages.

How to tell if a jalapeno chile pepper is hot:

A number of factors determine how hot the chile peppers get, like the variety and growing conditions—amount of water, ambient temperature, stress, and fertilizer used. It is interesting to note how even these variables are not necessarily consistent everywhere. In an article from the UC Division of Agriculture and Natural Resources, the restriction of water to induce stress hasn’t worked to produce a hotter chile pepper for them, but nitrogen levels look promising.

Unfortunately, we do not know the cultivar or growing conditions at the market, so we guess.

Fresh jalapeno peppers range between 2,500 and 10,000 Scoville units, which is somewhere between a hotter Anaheim and a milder Serano. The tricky part is knowing (or making a strong guess) as to which one is which. While there is no guarantee, I found the following guide to be more accurate than guessing.

A simple guide for selecting fresh jalapeno chile peppers:

Color: Fresh jalapenos range in color from light green (younger) to deep green to red (matured). The younger peppers are a lighter shade of green and likely more mild compared to darker green or red (red is harder to find in grocery stores). The photo above is an example of the various shades of green.
Texture: Younger peppers also have a smooth skin, as shown in the pepper on the left. Older, hotter jalapenos will have tan markings called corking on the surface, appearing like stretch marks. In the photo, this corking is evident on the dark green jalapeno on the right.
Age: Both the color and texture of the skin are indicators of a more mature, hotter jalapeno.

I tasted each of the peppers in the photo to test the above color and texture guide. On a scale from 1 to 10—from mild to hot—the jalapeno on the left (light green, smooth skin) was rated a 2, with a mild and bright flavor. The jalapeno on the right was rated a 9, with deep earthy heat that lingered. Even though it’s not a guarantee, I will use this guide when selecting jalapenos for recipes in the future.

The Taste Test:

The only sure way to truly know how hot a chile pepper will be is to actually taste it. However, don’t go chomping off the end if you’re a novice at this whole hot chile pepper game. The peppers in the photo below are the same chiles from the photo above—respectively, the two extremes from left to right. Notice the differences on the inside too; see more details in the tasting guide below.

Avoid a potentially painful experience with this jalapeno chile tasting guide:

⇒ Always wear food prep gloves when handling hot peppers and never touch your face or eyes while doing so.

Slice the pepper lengthwise. Notice the pith and rib the seeds clings to inside the pepper. Go ahead and discard the seeds since no one enjoys the texture and the real heat is in the rib.
Check the rib for a yellow line. The darker the line, the hotter it is. Unless you are used to eating incredibly hot raw peppers, don’t put it on your tongue—just trust me, this is the fire pit of the pepper.
Taste the flesh of the pepper first. This will still have some heat to it but will be mild compared to the rib or yellow line of capsaicin.
Depending on your impression of the green flesh, sample a tiny bit of the white rib (again, stay away from the yellow line) to determine if it belongs in your recipe.

BBQ Pulled Pork Stuffed Jalapenos is the easy kind of appetizer you need so there’s energy for the rest of your party plans.